Contrast, not a perfect sound

A phoneme is a category that helps distinguish words in a particular language variety. Its identity comes from the contrasts it participates in, not from a single ideal recording. English pin and bin illustrate a contrast at the beginning of a word. The two words can refer to different things, even when everything else in the pronunciation is held as similar as possible. The spelling is incidental to that argument.

One category, several realizations

The same category can have different pronunciations in different environments. Speakers also differ in voice quality, accent and speaking rate. An analysis groups together some of these differences while keeping other differences separate. This is why counting phonemes involves decisions about distribution, borrowed vocabulary and the variety being described. A number copied from a database should not be mistaken for a complete account of someone’s speech.

Read the evidence

Phonemic symbols conventionally appear between slashes, as in /p/. More detailed phonetic observations appear in square brackets. Neither notation is an audio recording. To decide whether a proposed difference is contrastive, look for a pattern across words and speakers, then check the source’s analysis. A small inventory is not evidence of a small expressive capacity: words and constructions combine the available categories in many ways.

THE THREAD TO KEEP

A phoneme is a contrastive category within a language variety, not a universally fixed sound.

Try it for yourself

In The sound switch, compare Place + voicing with Place only. Count which phonetic labels map to the same contrastive category.