An inventory is not enough
Knowing a language’s sound inventory does not tell you which sequences can form words. Phonotactics describes restrictions on combinations and positions. A consonant may occur at the end of a syllable but not the beginning, or may combine with some neighbors but not others. Two languages can therefore share many individual sounds while making quite different predictions about possible word shapes.
Separate impossible from unfamiliar
A form can be absent from a vocabulary without violating its sound patterns. An invented word may sound plausible because it follows those patterns even though it has no established meaning. Conversely, borrowed vocabulary, names and expressive forms can create peripheral patterns that differ from the common vocabulary. Researchers must state which layer of a lexicon and which variety their generalization describes.
Make a rule testable
A useful experiment defines a finite inventory and an explicit allowed pattern. It can then enumerate which strings pass and explain each rejection. This is a real calculation about an invented grammar, not a claim that a whole natural language has been captured. To investigate a real system, examine distributions across many documented words, including counterexamples. Probabilistic preferences and categorical restrictions should not be silently merged into one rule.
Phonotactics concerns which sound combinations occur and where; vocabulary membership is a separate question.
Try it for yourself
Use an invented inventory p, t, a and a CV-only rule. Explain why pa fits but pat fails even though every sound belongs to the inventory.
- Essentials of Linguistics, 2nd edition — 4.2 Phonotactics and natural classes (printed pp. 169–171)Catherine Anderson; Bronwyn Bjorkman; Derek Denis; Julianne Doner; Margaret Grant; Nathan Sanders; Ai Taniguchi · 2023, version 2.2 (February 2023), repository PDFRights & edition ↗
- Syllable StructureIan Maddieson · 2013; WALS Online v2020.6Rights & edition ↗